Thank you to everyone who came out to audition for the world premiere of The Legacy of Sarah Jane. We are so grateful for the interest that was shown for the mission of Sycamore Tree Theatre and this show in particular, which is both very personal but also very timely for our communities.

And with no further ado, here is the cast of The Legacy of Sarah Jane (2026).

The Ensemble – Townsfolk of Caddo Gap / Gospel Choir / Sarah Jane’s Descendents

Women

Denise Diffee	Leslie Day	Mataya Cook	Melanie Jackson
Merry McCallum	Michelle Knudson	Michelle Potter	Nathasya Pellerin
Richelle Rosioru	Teresa Fisher-Galvez

Men

Bruce Fitzgerald	Caleb Kotschevar	Cory Caulk
David Potter	Gabe Bombita	John Jones

Ensemble Kids/Teens (Vaughn Children / Young Folk of Caddo Gap)

Adelyn Cook	Annie Matthewson
Evie Matthewson	Hadley Fletcher
Reid Espiritu	Rylee Espiritu

Diffee and Vaughn Children (also Ensemble Kids/Teens)

Character	Actor	Character	Actor
Diffee Kids
Lillie Diffee	Lilli Haugo	John Diffee	Thomas Baker
Walter Diffee	Landon Knudson	Fannie Diffee	Madison Spilker
Roy Diffee	Vance Caulk	Claude Diffee	William Knudson
Hattie Diffee	Berlyn Thiel	Maidie Diffee	Henley Spilker
Vaughn Kids
Chester	Albert Knudson

Cast

Character	Actor
Sarah Jane Diffee	Brianne Mathews
Joe Diffee	Roger Wilson
Masie Vaughn	Kara Garcia
Billy Vaughn (also Ensemble)	David Potter
Sam (The Saloon Keeper) (also Ensemble)	Cory Caulk
Sheriff (also Ensemble)	Bruce Fitzgerald
Doc (also Ensemble)	John Jones
Leroy (also Ensemble)	Caleb Kotschevar
Ruby (also Ensemble)	Richelle Rosioru
Judge Parker	Tom Diffee
Regnal Gilmore (The Evangelist)	Paul Kawabori
Narrator	Tom Diffee